Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Greg Conners's avatar

American schools began teaching the concept of integrated planning in the late sixties or earlier seventies. In 1972, the board game CLUG (Community Land Use Game) was used in schools and colleges to teach aspiring government officials the same basic concepts you propose. I remember it well - planning over pizza. When I was appointed to the local Planning Commission a decade later, it was disappointing to realized the group was not much more than a zoning and variance board. And when our sub-committee insisted on beginning a state-mandated general plan review, we got push-back; boy, did we. The Chair of the Commission, the Mayor and City Council got together and decided we had a quorum problem (we did not - public record). With that lie, they cut the membership of the commission from nine citizens to five, leaving only the non-planner types in place to give them their concessions in the form of variances and conditional permits. That was more than thirty years ago. The city is a mess.

Planning to not plan is an option behind the scenes, and as long as money remains in politics it will play it's role. Hopefully, some will find ways to profit from your ideas; maybe they will be more likely to come to fruition. Thanks again for your writing.

Nancy Gray's avatar

Just a short note to highlight a principled stand of one man named Agee. He was and maybe still is a designer of airports. He was invited to make a design for the them about to be built Sacramento International Airport. At the time the site was surrounded by empty space.

When he discovered there was no plan to connect it to the city with the new light rail system being built he withdrew his participation. That space is now filled with an Amazon campus and wall to wall developments. No light rail. Just asphyxiating traffic.

5 more comments...

No posts

Ready for more?